Mutual Desires (Call Her Mommy) by Nina Sestina

Johnny is humiliated when his girlfriend breaks up with him. It's bad enough getting dumped, but it's even worse when she tells everyone about his browser history, and the fact that he likes older women. A couple days later, Sheila's mother Ashley reaches out to him, saying that he needs to come by her place to pick up his things. He doesn't care about the stuff, but he wants to see Ashley one more time, as he's harbored a secret crush on her since the first time he saw her.